Historical Facts about Advocacy · Chapter 7 of 7

The Mechanics of “VA Math” (Combined Ratings Table)

Many veterans are blindsided when they add up their individual disability percentages and find their actual monthly check is far lower than expected. This is because the VA does not use standard addition; it calculates disability based on a non-linear efficiency matrix of the “whole person.”

The Fundamental Rule: You Can Never Exceed 100% Whole

The VA looks at a healthy veteran as 100% whole. Every approved disability takes a bite out of what is left, not out of the original 100%.

Step-by-Step Scenario

Imagine a veteran is awarded three separate disabilities: 50% for PTSD, 30% for a back injury, and 10% for tinnitus.

Start: 100% Healthy

  1. Minus 50% (PTSD)50% Disabled · 50% Left Whole
  2. Minus 30% of REMAINING 50% (Back)15% More Disabled · 35% Left Whole
  3. Minus 10% of REMAINING 35% (Tinnitus)3.5% More Disabled · 31.5% Left Whole

Final Raw Score: 50% + 15% + 3.5% = 68.5% Rounded to the nearest 10% = 70% Combined Rating

  1. First Injury (Highest First): 50% of a whole person (100) = 50% Disabled. The veteran is now 50% “whole.”
  2. Second Injury: 30% of the remaining whole person (50) = 15% Disabled.
    • Combined total: 50% + 15% = 65% Disabled. The veteran is now 35% “whole.”
  3. Third Injury: 10% of the remaining whole person (35) = 3.5% Disabled.
    • Combined total: 65% + 3.5% = 68.5% Disabled.
  4. The Rounding Rule: The VA rounds the final total to the nearest 10% increment. 68.5% rounds up to a 70% Combined Disability Rating.

Advocacy Takeaway: Because of this diminishing return matrix, getting from 80% to 100% requires massive amounts of medical evidence, which is why advocates prioritize high-value primary claims and secondary conditions rather than scattering minor 10% claims.

A veteran with an “Other Than Honorable” (OTH) or Bad Conduct discharge is often stripped of their G.I. Bill, VA healthcare, and housing benefits. Historically, tens of thousands of veterans were pushed out with OTH statuses for minor misconduct that was actually the direct, behavioral byproduct of undiagnosed PTSD, Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), or Military Sexual Trauma (MST).

An advocate’s goal is to petition the respective service branch’s Discharge Review Board (DRB) or Board for Correction of Military Records (BCMR) to upgrade that status to “General Under Honorable Conditions” or “Honorable.”

In 2014 and 2017, Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel and Acting Principal Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness A.M. Kurta issued binding policy memos that changed the rules of engagement for advocates. These memos mandate that Review Boards must give “Liberal Consideration” to upgrade requests if the veteran can show a nexus between their trauma and their misconduct.

The 4-Part Upgrade Evidentiary Brief

To win a discharge upgrade under liberal consideration, an advocate must build a legal brief proving four exact pillars:

Discharge Upgrade Pillars
  1. Documented Service Trauma (PTSD/TBI/MST in-service)
  2. Clear Diagnosis (Current clinical evaluation)
  3. Behavioral Nexus (How trauma caused the misconduct)
  4. Post-Service Rehabilitation (Character references)
  1. In-Service Trigger: Proof that a traumatic event, combat deployment, or assault occurred during service.
  2. Clinical Diagnosis: A current, formal diagnosis from a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist specializing in trauma.
  3. The Behavioral Nexus: Expert medical testimony explaining how the trauma directly caused the behavioral infraction (e.g., how severe hypervigilance and self-medicating led to an unexcused absence/AWOL or a failed drug test).
  4. Mitigation & Character: Evidence of a stable, productive post-service civilian life, including steady employment, community volunteering, clean criminal records, and character reference letters.

Ultimate Digital Toolkit for Active Self-Advocacy

If you are ready to put this blueprint into immediate action, wrap up your research by bookmarking and utilizing these exact, secure digital portals:

Accuracy notes for this chapter

We checked the facts in this chapter. These statements were corrected or softened from the original text:

  • A.M. Kurta was Acting Principal Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness, not a Defense Secretary.
  • VA first rounds the combined value to a whole number, then to the nearest 10 (values ending in 5 round up). The 68.5% example still ends at 70%. Source (opens in a new tab)

In crisis right now? Call 988, press 1 or text 838255. It’s free and open 24/7.

Back to top