Self-Advocacy Toolkit · Chapter 5 of 5

Script: Reporting a Bad C&P Exam (Phone & Written)

If an examiner cuts your appointment short, ignores your symptoms, or displays bias, create a written record as soon as you can, ideally before VA makes a rating decision.

Part A: The Immediate Phone Call

Call VA at 1-800-827-1000 as soon as you can after your exam. (You can also call the exam contractor or use its satisfaction survey.) Adapt this script to your situation:

Phone script · reporting a deficient C&P exam
Hello, my name is [Your Name], and my VA file number is [Your VA File Number or Social Security Number]. I am calling to report a concern about a deficient Compensation and Pension exam conducted on [Date of Exam].
The examiner, [Doctor’s Name] from [Company Name, e.g., VES or Leidos QTC], did not conduct a complete and adequate exam. Specifically, the examiner [state the violation: e.g., did not use a goniometer to measure my range of motion / spent less than five minutes reviewing my severe PTSD / refused to look at my medical nexus letters].
Please document this complaint on my claim, and note that I am requesting a new, competent exam by a different provider before a rating decision is made.
Keep it in front of you during the call. Replace every highlighted [bracket] and describe only what actually happened.

Self-Advocacy Action: Write down the date and time of the call and the representative’s name (or ID, if they give one), and ask them to confirm the complaint has been documented. Then follow up in writing (Part B), because a phone note alone is easy to miss.

Part B: The Written Memorandum

Right after the call, submit a VA Form 21-4138 (opens in a new tab) using the layout below. If your claim is still pending, upload it with the claim status tool on VA.gov (opens in a new tab) (QuickSubmit is for other kinds of documents).

Copy-ready memorandum · VA Form 21-4138
MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD: CHALLENGE OF DEFICIENT C&P EXAMINATION
DATE OF EXAM: [Insert Date]
EXAMINATION TYPE: [e.g., Mental Health / Orthopedic]
EXAM PROVIDER: [e.g., VA medical center, Leidos QTC, VES, OptumServe, or Loyal Source]
1. PROCEDURAL DEFICIENCIES:
I am writing to formally object to the adequacy of the C&P examination conducted on the date listed above. I believe the examination was inadequate for rating purposes (38 CFR § 4.2) and did not follow VA’s examination guidance in the M21-1 Adjudication Procedures Manual. The examiner did not accurately assess my condition because of the following:
• [Bullet 1: e.g., The entire physical range of motion test was conducted visually without the use of a goniometer, which 38 CFR § 4.46 calls indispensable.]
• [Bullet 2: e.g., The examiner rushed the appointment, concluding a complex mental health review in under 10 minutes, preventing me from describing my chronic occupational impairment.]
• [Bullet 3: e.g., The examiner said they had not reviewed the private medical records and nexus letter already in my claim file.]
2. REMEDY REQUESTED:
Because this examination does not accurately reflect my current level of disability, it should be returned as inadequate for evaluation purposes (38 CFR § 4.2). I respectfully request that VA order a new exam with a different medical provider, consistent with VA’s duty to assist (38 CFR § 3.159).
Paste it into the statement section of VA Form 21-4138. The bracketed bullets are examples: replace them with what actually happened at your exam, and delete any that don’t apply.

A common misconception about Total Disability based on Individual Unemployability (TDIU) is that you can’t work at all. Under 38 CFR § 4.16 (opens in a new tab)(a), marginal employment is not considered substantially gainful employment, so you may be able to work and still qualify for TDIU. That includes low-income work and, depending on the facts, work in a protected environment.

Marginal Employment (The Poverty Line)

Marginal employment generally exists when your earned annual income does not exceed the poverty threshold for one person set by the U.S. Census Bureau (opens in a new tab) (for 2025, $16,749 for one person under 65; the figure changes every year). VA generally doesn’t treat that work as substantially gainful employment, even if it is a regular job, though it still considers the nature of the work.

Protected Work Environments (Above the Poverty Threshold)

If you earn more than the poverty threshold, VA can still find your work marginal “on a facts found basis,” for example when you work in a protected environment such as a family business or sheltered workshop. There is no set income cap for this, but VA decides case by case. In general, a protected environment means your employer makes accommodations that a typical employer would not.

Protected Work Environment Markers
  • Family Businesses: For example, a relative who excuses frequent absences. Named in 38 CFR § 4.16(a).
  • Sheltered Workshops: Work specifically designed for disabled individuals. Named in 38 CFR § 4.16(a).
  • Special Accommodations (example): Extra breaks, no penalty for missed deadlines, or time to step away when symptoms flare.

How to Prove Your Work is Protected

If VA asks you to verify your employment with VA Form 21-4140 (opens in a new tab) (Employment Questionnaire), or you apply for TDIU while working, report your work and earnings honestly and submit evidence that your job is protected:

  • An Employer Statement: A signed letter from your employer describing the accommodations you actually receive, for example: “We employ [Veteran’s Name] under specialized conditions. We allow them to leave work without notice during panic attacks, excuse frequent absences, and do not hold them to standard production quotas due to their service-connected disabilities.”
  • Medical Backing: A letter from your physician explaining that your ability to earn an income depends on these workplace accommodations.

Your Final Self-Advocacy Checklist

Keep this checklist handy to guide your actions as you move forward with any VA claim:

Final Self-Advocacy Checklist
  • File an Intent to File (VA Form 21-0966 (opens in a new tab)) to protect a potential effective date for back-pay.
  • Request your service records, including Service Treatment Records (STRs), from the National Archives through eVetRecs (opens in a new tab).
  • Read the 38 CFR Part 4 criteria for your specific diagnostic codes.
  • Write a 3-part Personal Statement focusing on functional limitations.
  • Request your C&P exam report (DBQ) with VA Form 20-10206 (opens in a new tab) after your exam.
  • Upload documents online (the claim status tool for a pending claim, QuickSubmit for other documents) and save each confirmation.
Accuracy notes for this chapter

We checked the facts in this chapter. These statements were corrected or softened from the original text:

  • This chapter comes from a second set of notes. The part of those notes that repeated Chapter 4 word for word was not duplicated here.
  • The phone script no longer asks VA to log “an electronic note” or for an “Employee ID number”: representatives may not give an ID, so the script asks you to record the name, date, and time. “Within 24 to 48 hours” isn’t a VA rule and was softened. The script asks for your VA file number or Social Security number; only give it on a call you placed to an official VA number. Source (opens in a new tab)
  • The memorandum (originally “The QuickSubmit Memorandum”) now goes to your pending claim through the claim status tool, because VA says QuickSubmit is for other documents. The goniometer citation was corrected from 38 CFR 4.40 (functional loss) to 4.46, which calls a goniometer “indispensable”. “Inadequate for evaluation purposes” comes from 4.2, and the duty to assist from 3.159. Source (opens in a new tab)
  • “Logistics Health” (LHI) is the former name of OptumServe’s exam business; the vendor list now names VA’s current contractors. “Contractually deficient” was removed because a veteran can’t know the contract terms. The example about records “I brought to the appointment” was changed because VA says the examiner can’t add papers you bring; submit them to your claim instead. Source (opens in a new tab)
  • “Maintain your 100% TDIU payout while working” and “no income limit” were softened. Under 38 CFR 4.16(a), marginal employment isn’t substantially gainful employment; earnings at or below the Census poverty threshold for one person generally count as marginal, and work above it can be marginal “on a facts found basis”, such as a family business or sheltered workshop. VA decides case by case. The other accommodations are examples, not a list from the regulation. Source (opens in a new tab)
  • The $16,749 figure is the Census Bureau’s 2025 poverty threshold for one person under 65. It changes every year; check the current table. Source (opens in a new tab)
  • VA Form 21-4140 is used when VA asks a TDIU recipient to verify employment. “Because your income flagged their system” couldn’t be confirmed and was removed. The employer letter is now framed as an example: it should describe only accommodations you actually get. Source (opens in a new tab)
  • eVetRecs is still the National Archives’ online request system, but most (not all) service records are kept there; some recent records are held elsewhere. The checklist items about intent to file, exam reports, and uploads now match Chapters 1, 3, and 4. Source (opens in a new tab)

In crisis right now? Call 988, press 1 or text 838255. It’s free and open 24/7.

Back to top